© Copyright Our Wall
The Shadow of the Erdtree DLC for Elden Ring has expanded the game’s already vast and intricate world with an array of new bosses. Among these are Remembrance Bosses, which are typically more difficult and rewarding than the usual enemies. These bosses come with Elden Ring Runes their own unique mechanics, challenging combat patterns, and lore-rich backstories, further enhancing the depth of the game. In this tier list, we’ll rank all the Remembrance Bosses in the Shadow of the Erdtree DLC, from the hardest to the easiest. We'll take into account both the difficulty and the lore significance of each boss, along with player feedback based on various blessing levels, builds, and strategies.
This tier list covers 34 bosses from the DLC, ranking them in terms of overall challenge and their contribution to the experience. While some bosses might seem easy on a second playthrough, they all bring a unique experience to the table. Let’s dive in!
1. Bayle the Dread – The Ultimate Dragon Challenge
Bayle the Dread takes the top spot as the hardest boss in Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree. This dragon boss offers a staggering challenge, especially at blessing level 18. His tough, armored body makes him difficult to damage, with his head being the primary weak spot, though it’s hard to land consistent hits. Bayle’s second phase introduces a massive difficulty spike, where he undergoes a super saiyan-like transformation, sprouting wings and launching meteors. The laser attack in this phase is particularly tricky to dodge due to its delayed explosion, making it a test of patience and reflexes. Using NPC summons like Egon can be a crucial part of the strategy to bring down this beast. Players who use anti-dragon weapons, like the Dragon Katana from Ancient Dragon-Man, can find some success, but it's not a universal solution for all builds. Overall, Bayle the Dread offers one of the most demanding and rewarding fights in the DLC.
2. Messmer the Impaler – The Deceptive Assassin
Messmer the Impaler is a boss that tests both your reflexes and your ability to read attack patterns. While his attack combos are well-telegraphed, they can be deceptively long and contain unexpected follow-ups, making his fighting style feel punishing. The second phase transforms him into a serpent man, giving him new attacks, but the dodge timings remain mostly similar to his first phase. His swift, multi-hit combos and the constant pressure he applies make this boss one of the harder fights in the DLC. Despite having a few tricks up his sleeve, Messmer is ultimately a fair and rewarding challenge.
3. Midra, Lord of Frenzied Flame – A Battle of Contrasts
Midra, Lord of Frenzied Flame starts off deceptively easy, with players able to bully him during the first phase, but it’s the second phase where things get chaotic. As Midra transforms into a fire orb-headed monster, the Madness resistance gear becomes crucial, though it’s not mandatory for winning the fight. The telegraphing in this boss fight is among the best in the DLC, allowing for a natural rhythm of dodging and counterattacking. What’s particularly refreshing about Midra is that he provides a fair challenge, with ample time for counterattacks without overwhelming the player with unnecessary hits.
4. Rellana, Twin Moon Knight – Relentless and Overwhelming
Rellana, the Twin Moon Knight, earns the fourth spot due to her relentless combat style. Her nine-hit combo is particularly overwhelming, and her triple-hit move is almost impossible to dodge unless you anticipate it. She uses a combination of magic greatswords and moonfall attacks, which can force the player to take a more defensive stance, especially when paired with her homing soul mass. Her fire attacks are brutal, and in her second phase, she becomes even more deadly, making this one of the more exhausting and relentless fights in the DLC.
5. Metry, Mother of Fingers – The Unpredictable Monster
Metry, Mother of Fingers, presents a challenge that lies more in the environmental hazards and the difficulty in reaching the fight than her attack patterns. Her finger-legs can run over players if they aren’t careful, making it a tricky fight to navigate. Although her attack patterns aren’t overwhelmingly difficult, the challenge of getting to her and dealing with the chaotic environment make her a formidable foe.
6. Demi-Human Swordmaster Onze – The Erratic Swordmaster
Demi-Human Swordmaster Onze might be the hardest easy boss or the easiest hard boss, depending on your perspective. His erratic jumping attacks make it difficult to track his movements, and the frost buildup from his magic sword adds another layer of danger. Despite his unpredictability, the fight remains manageable with practice and the right equipment, though the anxiety of dealing with his erratic behavior makes the fight more nerve-wracking than it may appear at first glance.
7. Death Knight – The Undead Warrior
Death Knights are challenging bosses due to their ability to heal themselves by grabbing players. While this ability makes them seem invincible at times, using charms that restore HP on critical hits can help turn the tide. Despite the fact that they can regenerate health from a single grab, they’re still manageable if you’re able to avoid their more dangerous attacks and keep up the pressure.
8. Divine Beast Dancing Lion – The Synchronized Challenge
Divine Beast Dancing Lion is a unique boss duo that is challenging due to its unpredictable movements and the dual nature of the fight. Essentially two characters in a lion costume, their synchronized attacks are a sight to behold. The spinning breath attack can be jumped over if timed correctly, but the added lightning strikes and elemental changes make it an increasingly difficult battle. Frost and shockwave attacks add additional layers of complexity, though wind attacks are easier to manage. The key here is learning the elemental changes and being ready to adapt to the new mechanics mid-fight.
9. Scadutree Avatar – The Three-Phase Surprise
The Scadutree Avatar might surprise many players by being easier than it seems. Despite its three-phase battle structure, this boss is surprisingly manageable. It takes a lot of damage to its sunflower face and doesn’t have many attacks that can catch players off-guard. The key to success here is dodging bleed thorns and avoiding the boss’s long-ranged attacks. The fight doesn’t drastically change between phases, making it one of the more predictable encounters.
10. Romina, Saint of the Bud – The Scarlet Rot Inflictor
Romina, Saint of the Bud, feels like a Dark Souls boss in spirit, with a combination of Scarlet Rot infliction and explosive attacks. Her attack patterns are manageable, but the rot she spreads makes this fight a lot more dangerous. Players will need to stay on top of status effects while avoiding her quick slashes and flame attacks. This adds an extra layer of difficulty, particularly when you’re already dealing with the poison or rot buildup.
11. Count Ymir – The Finger-Giving Boss
Count Ymir’s role in the game's lore is far more memorable than his actual fight. His ability to spawn finger creatures gives him a certain uniqueness, but he’s not particularly durable and can be defeated quickly. The fight itself is not difficult, but the lore behind Ymir is fascinating, adding weight to his presence in the DLC.
12. Ancient Dragon-Man – The Mundane NPC Battle
Ancient Dragon-Man stands out as one of the more mundane bosses in the DLC. His challenge level is low, and his mechanics aren’t anything special. The reward for defeating him—including powerful weapons and armor—is more significant than the fight itself, which is not especially difficult or memorable.
Conclusion
The Shadow of the Erdtree DLC for Elden Ring introduces a wealth of new and exciting Remembrance bosses, each offering unique challenges and lore-rich experiences. From the brutal Bayle the Dread to the more manageable Lamenter, the DLC provides a diverse array of encounters, testing players in different ways. Whether it’s through relentless aggression, intricate attack patterns, or status effects like Scarlet Rot and Madness, these bosses add a considerable amount of content to an already expansive game.
While the ranking presented here reflects the general difficulty curve, your playstyle, build, and buy Elden Ring Items blessing level will undoubtedly influence how you experience these bosses. Some fights may feel easier or harder based on your character’s strengths and weaknesses. Regardless, each boss brings something unique to the table, and mastering them will make for a truly rewarding experience in the Shadow of the Erdtree DLC.
The Wall